Detective Mark Halloway sat in his car, the city's lights casting a dim glow over the interior. The confrontation with James Sterling had left him with more questions than answers. Sterling’s fear was palpable, but it was what he wasn’t saying that gnawed at Halloway. The medallion in his pocket felt like a heavy weight, a constant reminder that he was dealing with something far beyond a simple murder investigation.
He needed a new approach. Sterling had been the leader, but he wasn’t the only one with secrets. The survivors had been through hell together, and Halloway was certain that they shared more than just the trauma of the shipwreck. Their stories had lined up too neatly, as if they had rehearsed them. But cracks were beginning to show, and it was time to exploit those weaknesses.
Halloway decided to visit Victoria Gray next. Victoria had been the most composed of the group, but there was a coldness to her, a detachment that seemed unnatural given the circumstances. She was an artist, known for her dark and unsettling work, and she had gained notoriety after the shipwreck, her art becoming even more macabre. Halloway suspected that her art held clues, subconscious reflections of the horrors she had witnessed—or perhaps caused.
Victoria lived in a loft in a gentrifying part of the city, the kind of place that was both trendy and isolated. Halloway buzzed the intercom and was met with a brief silence before the door clicked open. He climbed the stairs to her apartment, each step echoing in the narrow stairwell. When he reached her door, it was ajar, a thin line of light spilling into the hallway.
He knocked softly and pushed the door open, stepping into a large, open space filled with canvases, sculptures, and strange artifacts. The air smelled of paint and something else, something earthy and old. Victoria was standing by a large canvas, her back to him, her hands stained with black and red paint.
“I’ve been expecting you, Detective,” she said without turning around. Her voice was calm, almost serene, as if she were discussing the weather.
Halloway stepped further into the room, his eyes scanning the chaotic array of artwork. “You’ve been expecting me? Why’s that?”
Victoria turned to face him, a small smile playing on her lips. She was strikingly beautiful, with sharp features and eyes that seemed to pierce through him. “Because I knew you wouldn’t stop until you found the truth. And I knew it would lead you here.”
This tale has been pilfered from Royal Road. If found on Amazon, kindly file a report.
Halloway crossed his arms, trying to mask his unease. “And what truth is that, Victoria? What really happened on that island?”
She tilted her head slightly, studying him as if he were one of her unfinished sculptures. “The truth is subjective, Detective. We all experienced the same events, but we all interpreted them differently. The island… it has a way of getting inside your head, twisting your perceptions. What you think you know isn’t always what happened.”
“Enough with the riddles,” Halloway snapped. “I’m not here to analyze your art. I’m here to find out why four people died and why the rest of you are lying about it.”
Victoria’s smile faded, and she walked over to a small table, picking up a worn, leather-bound journal. She handed it to Halloway, her expression serious. “This is my journal from the island. Everything I saw, everything I felt, is in there. Read it, and you’ll understand.”
Halloway hesitated before taking the journal. The leather was cool to the touch, the pages yellowed with age. He flipped it open and began to read. The entries were chaotic, filled with sketches, notes, and ramblings that barely made sense. But as he read further, a pattern began to emerge—a pattern of fear, desperation, and something darker.
The journal described strange rituals, hallucinations, and a pervasive sense of being watched. Victoria wrote of a presence on the island, something ancient and malevolent, that seemed to feed on their fear. The survivors had found the medallion in a cave, surrounded by bones and ancient symbols. They had taken it, hoping it would lead to their rescue, but instead, it had unleashed a series of tragic events.
As Halloway read, he felt a chill creep up his spine. The journal wasn’t just a record of events; it was a confession. The survivors had been complicit in the deaths, whether by their actions or inaction. The medallion had brought out the worst in them, turning them against each other. And now, it seemed, it was trying to do the same to him.
He looked up at Victoria, who was watching him intently. “You knew this would happen, didn’t you? You knew that taking the medallion would curse you all.”
Victoria nodded slowly. “We were desperate. We thought it was our only chance. But we were wrong. The island… it doesn’t let go. It’s a part of us now, and we’re a part of it. There’s no escaping it.”
Halloway closed the journal, feeling a deep sense of dread. “So what now? What am I supposed to do with this?”
“Destroy it,” Victoria said softly. “Destroy the medallion, destroy the journal, and maybe, just maybe, you can break the curse. But be careful, Detective. The island doesn’t like to lose.”
Halloway nodded, slipping the journal into his coat pocket. He felt the weight of the medallion against his chest, heavier than before. He knew what he had to do, but the thought of returning to the island filled him with fear.
As he left Victoria’s loft, he couldn’t shake the feeling that he was being watched, that the island’s influence had followed him back to the city. The truth was unraveling, but at what cost?