The heavy rain pelted against the windows of the small office, the rhythmic drumming a constant backdrop to the late hour. Detective Mark Halloway leaned back in his worn leather chair, a steaming cup of coffee in his hand. The glow from his desk lamp cast long shadows on the walls, making the cramped space feel even smaller. He stared at the file in front of him, the one that had been plaguing his thoughts for days—the file that officially wasn’t his anymore.

“Shipwreck on the Aegean,” the cover read in bold letters, "Tragic Accident Claims Four Lives, Survivors Return Home.” The case had made headlines: a luxury yacht, a freak storm, and a miraculous survival against all odds.

The survivors’ statements were neatly typed out in the file, each one telling a similar story: a sudden storm, the ship wrecked against the rocks, and an ordeal of survival on a remote island. But something about it had never sat right with Halloway. The survivors’ stories were too clean, too well-rehearsed, as if they had been prepared for the inevitable questioning. And then there were the inconsistencies—the subtle hesitations, the things left unsaid.

The official report had been concluded months ago, the incident declared a tragic accident by the authorities. The survivors—James Sterling, Victoria Gray, Paul Henderson, and Nina Wells—had returned to their lives, shaken but alive. The media had quickly moved on, and so had most of the world. But not Halloway.

He picked up a photograph from the file, a grainy image of the survivors taken shortly after their rescue. Their faces were a mixture of relief and exhaustion, but there was something else—something lurking beneath the surface. It was a look he had seen before, in other cases, when people were hiding the truth.

Halloway couldn’t shake the feeling that there was more to the story. The survivors’ accounts seemed almost rehearsed, as if they had come to a silent agreement on what to say. And then there were the inconsistencies—the subtle contradictions in their statements, the gaps that couldn’t be easily explained away.

Reading on Amazon or a pirate site? This novel is from Royal Road. Support the author by reading it there.

He reached for his coffee cup, the liquid long gone cold, and took a sip. His mind was already racing with possibilities. What if the shipwreck hadn’t been an accident? What if the island held secrets that the survivors were too afraid to reveal? The idea of a curse seemed far-fetched, but Halloway had learned not to dismiss anything outright.

With a sigh, he set the cup down and opened the file again. This time, he wasn’t looking for answers. He was looking for the questions that hadn’t been asked. His eyes scanned the pages, noting every detail, every discrepancy.

As he read, a plan began to form in his mind. He would start by re-interviewing the survivors. The official investigation might be closed, but that didn’t mean he couldn’t pursue his own line of inquiry. He’d learned over the years that the truth often lay in the shadows, hidden from plain sight, and it was his job to bring it to light.

Halloway’s thoughts were interrupted by a knock on his office door. He looked up to see his colleague, Detective Sarah Moore, standing in the doorway.

“Working late again, Mark?” she asked with a hint of concern in her voice.

Halloway nodded. “Just going over an old case.”

Moore stepped inside, glancing at the file on his desk. “The shipwreck? I thought that was wrapped up months ago.”

“It was,” Halloway replied, his tone neutral. “But something doesn’t add up.”

Moore raised an eyebrow, familiar with Halloway’s intuition. “You think there’s more to it?”

“I do,” he said, his voice firm. “And I’m going to find out what.”

Moore nodded, trusting his judgment. “Well, if anyone can, it’s you. Just… don’t get too deep into it, okay? We’ve got enough on our plate as it is.”

Halloway offered a small smile. “I’ll be careful.”

As Moore left the office, Halloway turned back to the file. The unanswered questions, the hidden connections, the mystery of the island—it all called to him, pulling him deeper into the investigation. He knew this case would be different from the others, more personal, more dangerous. But that only made him more determined.

He reached for his pen and began jotting down notes, outlining his next steps. The interviews, the background checks, the search for any historical records about the island—he would leave no stone unturned. The survivors might have escaped the island, but Halloway was convinced that they hadn’t escaped the truth. And neither would he.