Detective Mark Halloway left the island later that day, the journal weighing heavily in his pocket. The words scrawled by Paul Henderson painted a picture far more disturbing than he had anticipated. Yet, there was still a crucial piece missing. Something had driven these survivors to the edge, and Halloway was determined to find out what it was.

Back on the mainland, Halloway knew his next step: he had to dig deeper into the survivors' pasts. The journal suggested that tensions had been brewing even before the shipwreck, but it didn’t explain why. The key to understanding the island’s horrors likely lay in the hidden connections between the survivors.

First on his list was James Sterling, the quiet, composed businessman whose calm demeanor had masked the trauma he carried. Sterling had been cooperative during the initial investigation, but Halloway had noticed subtle inconsistencies in his statements. Now, with fresh questions in mind, Halloway arranged to meet him at his home.

Sterling lived in a modest but well-kept house in the suburbs, far removed from the hustle and bustle of the city. When Halloway arrived, he was greeted by Sterling himself, who looked slightly surprised but not unwelcoming.

“Detective Halloway,” Sterling said, shaking his hand firmly. “I wasn’t expecting you. Is there something I can help you with?”

Halloway offered a small, disarming smile. “I’m revisiting a few details from the case, just to make sure everything is squared away. I’d appreciate it if you could spare some time to answer a few more questions.”

Sterling hesitated, his eyes narrowing ever so slightly. “Of course. Please, come in.”

Halloway followed him into the living room, taking in the surroundings. The house was neat, almost meticulously so, with a faint scent of lavender in the air. Sterling gestured for him to sit on a leather armchair, while he took the couch opposite.

“So, what do you need to know?” Sterling asked, his tone guarded.

Halloway leaned forward, his expression thoughtful. “James, I’ve been going over your account of what happened on the island. It’s clear that the experience was traumatic, but there are a few things that don’t quite add up. For instance, Paul Henderson’s journal suggests that tensions among the group were high even before the worst of the ordeal began. Can you tell me more about that?”

Sterling’s face remained impassive, but Halloway didn’t miss the slight tightening of his jaw. “It was a stressful situation, Detective. We were stranded, with limited resources and no hope of rescue. Of course, there were tensions.”

“Understandable,” Halloway agreed, nodding. “But what about before the shipwreck? Did any of you know each other before the trip?”

Sterling’s eyes flickered, a brief flash of something—recognition, perhaps—before he quickly masked it. “No, not really. We were all just passengers on the same ship. We didn’t have any connection before the wreck.”

The story has been illicitly taken; should you find it on Amazon, report the infringement.

Halloway watched him carefully, sensing that Sterling was holding something back. “You’re sure about that? Because it seems to me that there might have been more going on beneath the surface. The kind of tension that doesn’t just come from being stranded.”

Sterling’s composure faltered for a moment, a crack in the armor. He leaned back, crossing his arms. “Look, Detective, we all went through hell on that island. We were scared, we were desperate. Whatever happened, we just wanted to survive. I don’t see how digging into our pasts is going to help anything.”

Halloway held Sterling’s gaze, letting the silence stretch between them. Then, in a calm voice, he asked, “James, is there something you’re not telling me? Something that might explain what really happened on that island?”

Sterling looked away, his expression tense. He seemed to be weighing his options, considering how much to reveal. Finally, he sighed, rubbing his temples as if the memory itself was painful.

“There was… something,” he admitted reluctantly. “Something that started before we even set foot on that ship. But it’s not what you think.”

“Go on,” Halloway encouraged.

Sterling hesitated again, then continued. “It’s about Victoria Gray. I didn’t know her personally, but I’d heard of her. She had connections—powerful connections. There were rumors, whispers about her involvement in some… unsavory dealings. Nothing proven, but enough to make people wary. When we realized she was on the same ship, it put some of us on edge.”

“What kind of unsavory dealings?” Halloway pressed, his interest piqued.

“Smuggling, fraud, you name it,” Sterling said, his voice low. “Like I said, nothing was ever proven, but there were enough stories floating around to make you wonder. On the island, when things got desperate, those rumors started to resurface. People started pointing fingers, questioning each other’s motives. It wasn’t just about survival anymore; it was about trust. And trust was in short supply.”

Halloway absorbed this information, his mind working quickly. This was a significant development, one that could explain the underlying tension in the group. But it also raised more questions.

“Why didn’t you mention this before?” Halloway asked.

Sterling shook his head, looking weary. “Because it didn’t seem relevant at the time. We were just trying to stay alive. What good would it have done to bring up rumors and accusations?”

“It might have helped us understand what really happened,” Halloway said, his tone firm. “And it might help now. If there’s more to this story, James, I need to know.”

Sterling seemed to wrestle with himself, torn between the desire to protect his own secrets and the need to unburden himself. Finally, he leaned forward, lowering his voice to a near whisper.

“There’s more, but I’m not the one who can tell you. You need to talk to Nina Wells. She knew Victoria better than any of us. If anyone knows the truth, it’s her.”

Halloway nodded, his mind already turning to his next move. “Thank you, James. I appreciate your honesty. I’ll be sure to follow up with Nina.”

As Halloway stood to leave, Sterling reached out, his hand gripping the detective’s arm. “Be careful, Detective,” he warned, his voice filled with genuine concern. “This isn’t just about what happened on that island. There are people—powerful people—who don’t want the truth to come out. You’re digging into something much bigger than you realize.”

Halloway met Sterling’s gaze, his resolve unwavering. “I’ve faced worse, James. But I appreciate the warning.”

With that, he left Sterling’s home, his mind racing. The pieces were starting to fall into place, but the picture they formed was far more complex and dangerous than he had anticipated. As he headed toward his car, he knew that his next conversation with Nina Wells would be crucial.

Whatever secrets she held could be the key to unraveling the entire mystery. But Halloway also knew that the closer he got to the truth, the more perilous his investigation would become.