Back at the Ravenwood Police Department, which was really just a glorified bungalow with a "Serve and Protect" sign and an alarming shortage of decent coffee, Chief Inspector Paul Davis was holding down his side of the investigation – by which Sarah meant he was meticulously organizing his paperclips into size order.

Chief Davis was a creature of habit, a man who found comfort in routine and order, two things a murder investigation sorely lacked. Still, under that gruff exterior and penchant for bureaucratic precision beat the heart of a decent cop, even if he did sometimes remind Sarah of a sleepy bulldog guarding a donut shop.

"So, Bennett," he began, not looking up from his paperclip symphony, "the deceased Mrs. Whitmore. Any thoughts on how a socialite ends up taking a dip in the lake, fully clothed no less? Not exactly standard swimming attire."

"Unless you frequent those fancy, members-only midnight swims the Ravenwood elite are always whispering about," Sarah quipped, flipping through the preliminary report on Laura Whitmore. "Although something tells me skinny-dipping with the mayor wasn't exactly Mrs. Whitmore's style."

Davis grunted, finally abandoning his paperclips. "Her husband's on his way in. James Whitmore. Heard he's taken this whole thing rather hard. Man of few words, usually. Could be grief, could be guilt. You’ll have to decipher that particular code, Bennett.”

Deciphering people was far more in Sarah's wheelhouse than deciphering the ancient hieroglyphics that constituted the department’s coffee machine instructions. She had a knack for reading between the lines, for spotting the telltale tics and inconsistencies that betrayed even the most practiced liars.

James Whitmore arrived looking less like a grieving husband and more like a thundercloud impersonating a human. He was a tall, imposing man, his face etched with a lifetime of hard living and even harder drinking, if the rumors about his fondness for whiskey were to be believed.

He slumped into the chair across from Sarah, his eyes bloodshot and his movements jerky.

"Mr. Whitmore, I'm Detective Bennett," Sarah began, offering him a sympathetic smile that didn’t reach her eyes. “I understand this is a difficult time, but I need to ask you a few questions about your wife."

Whitmore grunted, running a hand through his thinning hair. “Laura… she liked to swim. Early morning dips. Said it cleared her head.”

“Even fully clothed and at the crack of dawn?” Sarah pressed gently, noting the way his eyes darted to the side, avoiding her gaze.

"Look, I don't know," Whitmore snapped, his voice rising. "Maybe she liked to feel fancy while she floated with the fishes. Maybe she got tangled in some weeds. All I know is, my wife is dead, and it's tearing me apart!"

His outburst ended as abruptly as it began, leaving behind a heavy silence punctuated by the ticking clock on the wall.

"Mr. Whitmore, I understand this is a difficult time," Sarah started, her tone sympathetic yet firm, "but it’s crucial you tell me everything you can about your wife’s last 24 hours."

Whitmore ran a hand through his thinning hair, looking more like a harried businessman than a grieving widower. “Laura… she kept to herself. Always busy with her charities, her galas, her… friends.” He spat out the last word like it left a bad taste in his mouth.

"Friends? Did your wife have any… close friends? Anyone who might have wanted to harm her?"

“Laura wasn’t the type to make enemies,” he said, a touch too quickly, “but she had… acquaintances. People who envied her, maybe.”

“We’re investigating all possibilities, Mr. Whitmore,” Sarah said quietly. "I understand you and your wife were... estranged?"

This story has been stolen from Royal Road. If you read it on Amazon, please report it

Whitmore clenched his jaw, his face hardening even further. “We had our differences, like any couple. But I loved her.”

Sarah wasn’t entirely convinced, but she made a note to look into the "differences," which, according to Ravenwood gossip, were less disagreements over what color to paint the guest room and more full-blown, Shakespearean-level drama.

Next up was Clara Reynolds, Laura Whitmore’s personal assistant and confidante, at least according to the society pages Sarah had skimmed through.

Clara was the polar opposite of her employer’s husband. She was composed, elegant, with a voice as smooth as melted chocolate and eyes that held a shrewd intelligence. If James Whitmore was a thundercloud, Clara Reynolds was a spider web – delicate yet deceptively strong, capable of ensnaring unsuspecting prey.

"Mrs. Whitmore spoke very highly of you, Ms. Reynolds," Sarah began, her gaze steady on the other woman.

"Laura was… a force of nature," Clara replied, a flicker of something unreadable crossing her perfectly composed features. "She lived life on her own terms, always pushing boundaries, testing limits.”

“Did anything seem amiss lately? Was Mrs. Whitmore acting unusual, worried about anything?”

Clara hesitated, just a flicker of a pause. "Laura was a private person, Detective. She kept her concerns to herself."

“Did she have any enemies? Anyone who might have wished her harm?”

Clara hesitated, a delicate hand hovering over the pristine pearl necklace at her throat. "Laura was… loved. Admired. But like anyone in her position, she had her share of rivals, competitors."

“And what about you, Ms. Reynolds? Did you ever feel like you were competing with Laura… Mrs. Whitmore?”

A faint smile played on Clara’s lips. "We had an understanding, Laura and I. We knew our roles, respected each other's strengths. We were a team.”

A team with secrets, Sarah thought, filing away the carefully chosen words and calculated pauses for later analysis. There was a sharpness beneath Clara’s polished exterior, a hint of steel in her gaze that suggested she knew more than she was letting on.

Finally, it was Ethan Blake’s turn. He’d been relegated to the waiting area, where he sat nervously clutching a fishing magazine and avoiding eye contact with a framed portrait of a particularly stern-looking police chief from the 1970s.

The poor fisherman was still recovering from his early morning discovery, his usual jovial demeanor replaced by a somber solemnity.

“Alright, Ethan,” Sarah started gently, "Let's talk about you and Mrs. Whitmore."

Ethan practically choked on his own spit. "Me? And Mrs. Whitmore? We didn't… I mean, there's nothing to tell."

"Except for the fact that you two were an item a few years back,” Sarah said mildly, enjoying the way his face flushed a delicate shade of pink that clashed spectacularly with his orange fishing vest.

“Ancient history,” Ethan mumbled, staring intently at the fishing magazine as if it held the answers to all of life's mysteries.

“Ancient history that ended badly, by the looks of it,” Sarah pressed. “Did you ever quite get over her, Ethan?”

Ethan looked up, his eyes wide and wounded. “That’s… that’s not fair, detective. I was over her. I mean, we moved on. It was just… seeing her like that, it brought back…”

He trailed off, and Sarah let the silence hang in the air, giving him time to stew in his own discomfort.

“Did she ever mention any problems in her life, Ethan? Anything that might point to why someone would want to hurt her?”

“She… she mentioned feeling like someone was watching her,” Ethan blurted out, his voice barely above a whisper. “Like she couldn’t escape her own shadow.”

“Interesting,” Sarah murmured, making a note in her notepad. “Anything else?”

Ethan hesitated, then shook his head. “That’s all I remember. It’s just… Laura, she had this light about her, you know? It’s hard to imagine that light going out.”

Sarah left Ethan to his fishing magazine and returned to her desk, her mind buzzing. Each interview had added another layer to the puzzle, but none had provided a clear picture of what had happened to Laura Whitmore.

Later that evening, after the station had emptied and the only sounds were the hum of the fluorescent lights and the mournful wail of a distant siren, Sarah found herself back in Laura Whitmore’s mansionsifting through Laura’s belongings in her elegantly appointed study. It was like stepping into the pages of a glossy magazine – everything perfectly arranged, tastefully expensive, and strangely impersonal.

It was then, while examining Laura's impossibly organized desk, that Sarah noticed it – a tiny discrepancy in the arrangement of books on the shelf, a subtle difference in the pattern of the wood grain.

It was a hidden compartment, cleverly disguised and easily missed. Inside, nestled amongst old photographs and yellowed letters, lay a leather-bound diary, its pages filled with a spidery script.

Sarah opened the diary, her pulse quickening. This, she suspected, was where the real story began. The story Laura Whitmore had kept hidden from the world, a story that whispered of secrets, lies, and perhaps even the reason for her untimely demise.