As the ethereal courtroom settled into a calm quiet, the Judge turned to his assistant, who stood silently by his side. The assistant's eyes were filled with curiosity and thought.

"Do you think James understood the weight of his choices?" the assistant asked softly.

The Judge sighed, his ancient eyes reflecting a deep well of wisdom. "Understanding the weight of our choices is a journey," he said thoughtfully. "At the moment, our decisions often seem right. But as time goes on, we see their full impact."

The assistant nodded, thinking about the Judge's words. "It's strange. Our choices with good intentions often seem foolish when we look back. We act with our knowledge, but later, we learn more."

"Yes," the Judge agreed, a faint smile on his lips. "We're limited by what we know at the time. James chose Peter Pettigrew as his Secret Keeper because he thought it was the safest choice. He couldn't see Peter's betrayal coming."

"But does that make his decision any less foolish?" the assistant asked, frowning.

"Not foolish," the Judge said gently. "It makes it human. Regret is natural because it shows we've learned. When we look back and see our mistakes, it means we've gained wisdom."

The assistant's expression softened. "So, our regrets show we've grown."

"Exactly," the Judge affirmed. "Regret isn't just a burden; it's a teacher. It helps us make better choices in the future."

The assistant glanced toward the doorway where James had left, a thoughtful look on their face. "James will carry his regrets and the wisdom they bring."

"And that's the key," the Judge said. "Our past decisions shape who we are. It's how we use that wisdom in the future that matters."

The assistant nodded, feeling a new sense of purpose. "Thank you, Judge. Your words have given me a lot to think about."

The Judge smiled kindly. "Remember, everyone's journey is unique. Our job isn't to judge the past too harshly but to guide and support those who want to learn from it. Regret shows that we care about our actions and their effects on others. It means we're willing to change and grow."

He paused, looking deep into the assistant's eyes. "When we regret something, it means we've learned a valuable lesson. It's a sign that we're becoming better people. James made mistakes, but he also showed great courage and love. His regrets will help him guide his son Harry, and that's what matters most."

The assistant looked thoughtful. "So, our mistakes and regrets are part of what makes us human. They help us grow and become wiser."

"Yes," the Judge agreed. "And as we grow, we can help others on their journeys too. That's the true meaning of wisdom."

The assistant smiled, but then their expression grew serious. "Speaking of journeys, Judge, who is the next soul to be judged?"

The Judge's eyes darkened slightly as he turned to his assistant. "The next judgment is a challenging one," he said slowly. "It's Dolores Umbridge."

The assistant's eyes flickered in surprise. "Dolores Umbridge? She has caused so much pain and suffering. How do we approach her judgment?"

The Judge's face was solemn. "Her actions were indeed harmful, but we must look at the whole of her life, her choices, and the reasons behind them. We need to understand her motives, no matter how twisted they might seem. Every soul deserves a fair judgment."

The assistant nodded, albeit with a hint of apprehension. "It's hard to imagine finding any good in her actions."

"It will be a difficult judgment," the Judge acknowledged. "But remember, our task is not to condemn, but to seek understanding and offer a chance for redemption. Even the darkest souls can teach us something about ourselves and the nature of humanity."

Taking a deep breath, the assistant squared its virtual eyes. "I'm ready, Judge."

The Judge nodded, a look of resolve on his face. "Then let us proceed. Summon Dolores Umbridge."

As the assistant moved to carry out the Judge's command, the ethereal courtroom seemed to brace itself for the next chapter in its timeless duty. The path ahead was fraught with challenges, but it was a necessary journey to uncover the truths that lay hidden within every soul.

The ethereal courtroom buzzed with an almost tangible tension as Dolores Umbridge stepped forward, her face a mask of forced composure. She blinked, trying to clear her vision, convinced she was still in her cell in Azkaban and that this was just another torment conjured by the Dementors. But the surroundings were too vivid, too real.

"Dolores Jane Umbridge," the Judge began, his voice echoing with an ancient authority. "You stand here to be judged for your actions in life, both seen and unseen, known and unknown. Your path is one of ambition, cruelty, and deceit, wrapped in a facade of sweetness and propriety. The time has come to weigh your deeds and the true nature of your soul."

Umbridge's lips pursed into a tight line, her eyes darting around the room in search of an escape that did not exist. She squared her shoulders, her pink cardigan and neatly pressed skirt a stark contrast to the severity of the moment. "This is some sort of illusion," she muttered to herself, "a trick of Azkaban."

The Judge's expression remained impassive. "This is no illusion, Dolores. This is your reckoning."

She shook her head, her eyes wide with disbelief. "I have always served the Ministry," she began, her voice tinged with a brittle confidence. "I upheld the law and maintained order."

The Judge's gaze hardened. "The law you upheld was often twisted to suit your purposes, and the order you maintained was rooted in cruelty and oppression. Your actions went beyond mere governance—they inflicted pain and suffering on many."

If you encounter this story on Amazon, note that it's taken without permission from the author. Report it.

As the Judge spoke, memories of her past flashed in the air: her harsh punishments at Hogwarts, the implementation of the Muggle-Born Registration Commission, and her unwavering loyalty to a corrupt regime.

She recoiled from the images, shaking her head more vigorously. "No, this isn't real. I'm in Azkaban. This is just another nightmare."

The Judge leaned forward, his eyes boring into hers. "You cannot escape the truth, Dolores. It is time to face the consequences of your actions."

Umbridge trembled, her bravado slipping away. "But I did what was necessary... for the greater good... for order," she whispered, her voice cracking.

"The greater good?" the Judge echoed. "Or your ambitions? Your desire for power and control? The pain you inflicted was never justified by any higher purpose."

Tears of frustration and fear welled up in Umbridge's eyes. "I... I only followed orders," she stammered, grasping for any defense.

The Judge's voice softened, but the authority remained. "You chose to follow those orders, Dolores. You chose to embrace cruelty and hatred. Now, you must answer for those choices."

Dolores Jane Umbridge's heart raced as she tried to grasp the gravity of the situation. "This cannot be real," she murmured, her eyes darting around the ethereal courtroom. The Judge's presence felt almost dreamlike, and the pristine white walls only added to her disorientation. She reached up to adjust her pink cardigan, the familiar fabric feeling strangely out of place in this surreal setting.

Her mind raced back to her past, a tangled web of family dynamics and personal failures.

The Judge paused, allowing the words to sink in, before continuing with a somber tone. "Consider, if you will, the origins of the beliefs that shaped you. Orford Umbridge, your father, was a man of deep contradictions. He chose to marry Ellen Cracknell, a Muggle woman, which might seem, at first glance, a gesture of progress. Yet, beneath this facade of unity lay a fragile tolerance, a veneer that cracked under the pressure of his prejudices."

The Judge's voice grew more deliberate, emphasizing each point with measured clarity. "The true strain began with the birth of your younger brother, a Squib—an individual devoid of magical abilities. To Orford, this was not merely a personal disappointment but a damning indictment of Ellen's influence. He saw your brother's lack of magic as a blemish on his pure bloodline, an imperfection tainted by Ellen's Muggle heritage."

He continued, his tone heavy with the weight of judgment. "Orford's disdain grew with each passing year, transforming his marriage into a battleground of contempt and scorn. The bond between Orford and Ellen deteriorated, leading to a bitter and irrevocable divorce. Ellen and your brother were cast aside, retreating to the Muggle world, severed from the magical world and you."

The Judge's gaze seemed to pierce through the veil of time and illusion, focusing intently on Umbridge. "As a child, you absorbed your father's disdain like a sponge. Your mother and brother were mere footnotes in your life, easily dismissed and forgotten. Under Orford's influence, you learned to view them with contempt, internalizing a belief that shaped your character. The disdain for your Muggle heritage and your brother's lack of magic became central to your identity."

The Judge's voice softened, almost mournful. "It is this twisted legacy, born of prejudice and cruelty, that you carried into your adult life. It is this very legacy that now stands before you, to be examined and judged. The time has come to face the full measure of your actions and the true nature of your soul."

The scene shifted, and Dolores found herself transported back to her childhood home. She watched in detached horror as a younger version of herself sneered at her mother and brother. The bitterness in her voice was clear even then, and she felt a pang of something—regret, perhaps, or a distant echo of a lost familial bond.

The younger Dolores, with her nose lifted high, glared at her Muggle mother, Ellen Cracknell, who stood by the kitchen counter. Her face was weary, a stark contrast to Dolores's sharp and condescending expression. "Why must you be so insufferably ordinary?" the younger Dolores demanded, her tone dripping with disdain. "Can't you see how your pathetic Muggle ways are dragging us down?"

Ellen's face fell, her eyes welling with unshed tears. She tried to maintain her composure, though her shoulders slumped under the weight of her daughter's cruelty. "Dolores, please, don't speak to me like that. We're still family, despite our differences."

Young Dolores's eyes narrowed. "Family? Don't be foolish. You're nothing more than a burden. You and that Squib of a brother are a stain on our family's reputation."

Dolores watched her younger self's contempt with a mixture of disbelief and cold satisfaction. Her father, Orford Umbridge, entered the room, his face a mask of stern disapproval. "Dolores!" he scolded, though his voice held more exasperation than genuine anger. "You need to learn respect, even for those who are beneath us."

The younger Dolores straightened, her expression softening slightly as she turned her attention to her father. "But Father, why should I waste my respect on them? They're not like us. They don't belong in our world."

Orford's face hardened. "It's not about belonging. It's about maintaining our family's honor. Your mother and brother are a necessary inconvenience, but that doesn't mean you need to lower yourself to their level."

Dolores's gaze shifted to her younger brother, who stood silently in the corner, his face a picture of quiet misery. He was pale and thin, clearly affected by the harsh treatment. "Why don't you just leave us alone?" Dolores sneered at him. "Your very existence is an embarrassment. I wish you'd just disappear."

Her brother looked away, unable to meet her gaze, while Ellen's tears fell freely now. The weight of their shared pain was palpable.

The Judge's voice interrupted the painful recollection, cutting through Dolores's lingering resentment. "Dolores, do you see the roots of your disdain? This treatment of your family, your harshness, and your willingness to abandon any sense of empathy—these are the building blocks of the person you became. What do you have to say for these actions?"

Dolores, her face flushed with shame, struggled to meet the Judge's gaze. "It was... it was just the way I was taught. I believed it was right to maintain our superiority. I never considered how wrong I was—how I was shaped by my father's prejudice."

The Judge's expression remained impassive. "And yet, you allowed these beliefs to fester and dictate your actions throughout your life. The past cannot be undone, but understanding it is the first step towards redemption—or further downfall."

Dolores's eyes fell to the floor as she grappled with the weight of the Judge's words, the echoes of her past actions reverberating through her mind.

The Judge's voice grew softer, reflecting a more personal note. "You were also reminded of your nature by Garrick Ollivander, who observed that abnormally short wands often selected those with stunted moral character rather than mere physical attributes. This insight, however, did not prompt you to reflect on or amend your ways. Instead, you chose to ignore the implications of Ollivander's observation, allowing your flawed nature to persist unchallenged."

"At Hogwarts, you were Sorted into Slytherin," the Judge said, the image of a young Dolores in green and silver robes appearing before her.

The Judge's tone turned even more contemplative. "You were never appointed as a Prefect or Head Girl. Your Head of House, Horace Slughorn, found you to be lacking in qualities he esteemed. His opinion of you was unflattering, describing you as an 'idiotic woman'. This exclusion fostered a deep sense of resentment and frustration within you, further fueling your drive to attain power through any means necessary."

The Judge's gaze softened, almost mournful. "You left Hogwarts, not as a leader, but as one determined to climb the ranks through any means necessary. Your ambitions were overshadowed by your frustrations and a relentless desire to prove yourself, no matter the cost."

Umbridge's lips tightened into a thin line as the Judge's words echoed around her. The reality of her situation began to crystallize, her attempts to dismiss it as an illusion fading under the weight of the Judge's relentless scrutiny.