Novels2Search
Love or Hate
Chapter 1: The Proposal

Chapter 1: The Proposal

Alexia Marque stood in the dim hallway outside her apartment, the crumpled eviction notice clutched in her hand. The inked words blurred before her green eyes as frustration boiled over. Another setback. Another cruel twist.

She turned sharply and pushed through the door into her studio, her haven of paint-splattered chaos.

Setting the notice on the counter, she let her fingers linger on the edge as though grounding herself. Her reflection in the cracked mirror above the sink stared back, raw and unrelenting. The vibrant red waves of her hair fell over her shoulders, mocking the fiery temper she struggled to contain.

“Damn it,” she muttered, her voice tight with unshed tears.

A sharp knock at the door interrupted her thoughts. She wasn’t expecting anyone.

Opening the door, she froze. Elliot Cummings stood there, infuriatingly composed, his tall frame cloaked in an effortlessly tailored suit. His sharp blue eyes locked onto hers, regret in their depths.

“Alexia,” he said, his deep voice calm and measured. His presence filled the doorway like an undeniable force.

“What are you doing here, Elliot?”

“I heard about your situation,” he said, stepping inside without waiting for an invitation. “You’re being evicted.”

“And what? You’re here to swoop in and save the day?”

Elliot’s lips curved into a faint, almost bitter smile. “Something like that.”

Her temper flared, but she kept it in check. “I don’t need your pity. You made your choice when you walked away five years ago.”

“This isn’t about pity,” he said. “This is about giving you an opportunity.”

Alexia let out a sharp laugh. “An opportunity? From you? That’s rich. What is it, Elliot? Another deal where I come out worse than before?”

He didn’t flinch at her words. Instead, he reached into his pocket and pulled out a sleek black envelope, setting it on the counter between them. “Read it.”

She hesitated, then grabbed the envelope, sliding out a crisp sheet of paper. Her eyes scanned the elegant typeface.

Exclusive Artist-in-Residence Contract.

She glanced up at him, skepticism etched across her face. “You want me to create art for you?”

“Not just for me,” he said. “For one of my private ventures. High-end, exclusive pieces for a discerning clientele.”

“And why would I agree to this?”

Elliot leaned forward, his presence magnetic. “Because you need a fresh start. And because I’m offering you more than just a studio.”

“What else are you offering?”

He straightened, his expression unreadable. “I’ve already arranged for a fully equipped studio. All your materials, canvases, and tools will be transported. You’ll have a space that allows you to focus solely on your work. No distractions. No barriers.”

Alexia’s skepticism deepened. “And where exactly is this magical studio?”

Elliot’s lips twitched slightly. “My place.”

Her laugh was sharp and humorless. “You expect me to move in with you? Are you out of your mind?”

“It’s practical,” he said, unfazed. “You’ll have privacy and the resources you’ve always needed.”

“And what’s in it for you?” she demanded. “Why now, Elliot? Why do you suddenly care after five years?”

His blue eyes softened, a moment of vulnerability breaking through his controlled exterior. “Because some things don’t change, no matter how much time passes.”

She swallowed hard, caught off guard by the sincerity in his voice. “You’re five years too late.”

“Maybe I am,” he admitted. “But I’m here now, offering you a chance to rebuild. To focus on your art without worrying about the next eviction notice or gallery rejection.”

Alexia looked down at the contract again, the polished paper heavy in her hands. It was everything she’d dreamed of and everything she hated about him all at once. Dependence on Elliot Cummings felt like signing away her soul. Yet the alternative was bleak.

“I’ll think about it.”

“Think what you want, but this deal is your best option. You have 24 hours to decide.”

Alexia’s fingers clenched the contract tighter. “And if I say no?”

“Then you walk away, and I won’t intervene again. No safety net. No lifeline. I’ll respect your choice, Alexia. But consider carefully if you’re willing to lose this opportunity.”

Elliot moved to leave, pausing at the door. “By the way,” he added, his voice deceptively calm, “I’ve already arranged for a moving service to pack and transport your studio supplies—only if you agree. If not, I’ll cancel it.”

Alexia’s heart raced as he disappeared into the hallway. She sank onto the worn couch, the contract crumpling slightly in her trembling hands. His words settled deep in her chest, heavy and unyielding.

Her gaze drifted to the eviction notice on the coffee table, and her stomach churned. No options felt right. No escape felt clean.

A sharp knock jolted her from her thoughts. She froze. It was too soon for him to return.

Slowly, she crossed the room and opened the door just a crack.

A man stood there, unfamiliar, his face obscured by the brim of a baseball cap. He slipped an envelope through the gap, his voice low. “For you. Courtesy of Mr. Cummings.”

Alexia’s breath skipped as she stared at the envelope, the stranger already walking away. She hesitated, then tore it open, her pulse pounding.

Inside was a simple handwritten note in Elliot’s unmistakable handwriting:

You’re not as alone as you think. The choice is yours, but don’t look back.

The paper shook in her hands as the weight of her decision loomed larger than ever.

The story has been stolen; if detected on Amazon, report the violation.

Meanwhile, Elliot stepped into the back seat of his sleek black limousine. A minute later, the driver’s door opened, and his chauffeur got in and took off the cap.

“Mr. Cummings, it’s delivered.”

“Thank you, Jonathan.”

Elliot’s mind replayed the image of Alexia standing there, fierce and unyielding despite everything she’d been through. He knew he had hurt her, and seeing the consequences of his actions only deepened his resolve. This time, he wouldn’t let her down.

Back in her studio, Alexia paced the room, her thoughts a storm of doubt and anger. She glanced at her unfinished canvases, the eviction notice, and the contract side by side.

One represented the crushing weight of her reality; the other, the uncertain promise of a future she wasn’t sure she could trust.

She grabbed a brush, her fingers smudged with leftover paint, and swiped bold strokes across a blank canvas. Colors clashed and swirled, echoing the chaos within her.

Each stroke felt like a scream she couldn’t voice, the colors clashing in a way that almost hurt to look at. It was everything she didn’t want to admit—chaos and desperation poured onto the canvas.

The painting didn’t have a name, didn’t have a purpose; it was raw emotion spilled onto the canvas.

“Damn you, Elliot!”

The brush paused mid-stroke as her green eyes focused on the contract again. She knew she couldn’t delay forever. The clock was ticking, and Elliot Cummings always got what he wanted.

But this time, she promised herself, it would come at a cost he would never anticipate.

Alexia sat on her broken couch, and the once vibrant chaos of her space was gone. Now replaced by half-packed boxes and scattered paintbrushes littered on the floor, with the faint smell of drying paint.

Her fingers trembled slightly as she picked up the brush again, dabbed it in crimson and black, and each erratic stroke screamed her frustration and resentment, but no relief followed.

Her phone buzzed; she reached for it and stared at one word... “Accept?”

“Damn it! Damn you, Elliot! Damn it anyway!”

She typed: “I accept. Need 2 hours, packers can come.”

She stared at the screen for a long moment. Was she really doing this? But the reality of her situation forced her hand. She pressed send. There was no going back now.

Her phone buzzed again. She read his response: “Thank you, packers arrive in three hours.”

“Damn you, Elliot! I hate you!”

She wasn’t sure what hurt more, accepting the deal or the sting of knowing just how much power she had lost.

“I hate you, Elliot! Breathe... stop.”

She closed her eyes, the finality of it sinking in. There was no choice left.

Her gaze fell on the finished canvas in front of her; she named it “HATE.”

Now, there was nothing but the slow ticking of time before everything... changed.

Thirty minutes later, Alexia drove up the long, winding driveway until the mansion appeared ahead; its grandeur is impossible to ignore. She’d known it was going to be enormous, but nothing had prepared her for the sheer magnitude of it.

She parked in front of the grand entrance, stepping out of her car with a mix of nausea and awe twisting her stomach.

Her eyes swept over the place, taking in the polished marble columns, manicured hedges, and the fountain that stood like an imposing statue in the center of the drive. It was the type of wealth that wasn’t meant to be questioned, only worshiped.

As she walked up the stone steps to the front door, Georgia, the housekeeper, opened the door and greeted her with practiced professional warmth.

“Welcome, Miss Marque,” said Georgia. “Mr. Cummings has arranged everything.”

“Thank you,” Alexia replied, forcing herself to step inside carrying her wet canvas, crossing the threshold of the home she never thought she’d enter.

The interior was just as overwhelming as the exterior. The high ceilings, the crystal chandeliers, the intricate marble floors. Lavish didn’t even describe it. Yet, it felt cold, like a showpiece, not a home.

Georgia led her through the house, giving her a tour, but Alexia could barely take it all in. The décor, modern yet antique, screamed opulence. But to Alexia, it was too much. Too perfect. Too polished.

Finally, they reached the wing that had been prepared for her. As Georgia opened the door, Alexia was hit with the full force of the space: the living quarters, 2,000 square feet of tasteful luxury. Every inch was designed, from the upholstered furniture to the hand-painted silk curtains that draped over the windows.

The first thing Alexia noticed when she entered her bedroom was the designer clothing hanging in the closets along with displayed designer purses, bags, shoes, and even perfume... all the things she had never had access to, or wanted, until now.

Alexia said nothing in response. Not that she was ungrateful, but the idea of having every detail of her life arranged for her, including what she ate, gnawed at her. It was too much control, too much convenience.

But as her eyes skimmed over everything, she couldn’t shake the feeling of being manipulated. The clothes were chosen for her; the perfume selected for her, and the bed linens were what she would have picked herself.

“Your personal housekeeper, Anna, is assigned to help you settle in.”

Alexia didn’t acknowledge it. Her gaze shifted to the studio door at the far end of the room. She was already dreading the moment she would have to face the art space Elliot had arranged.

Georgia watched her. “Would you like to see your private kitchen?”

“Sure.”

It was exactly what she had expected—state-of-the-art appliances. Everything stocked to perfection. But as Georgia rattled off the details about what was provided, all Alexia could focus on was how detached she felt from the space.

“Dinner is at 7 pm sharp every night; breakfast is served at 7 am. Alexia barely registered the details, but she did note that the housekeeper, driver, and chef were all at her disposal.

Alexia barely acknowledged her, her eyes now fixed on a door at the far end of the room. The STUDIO.

She didn’t wait for Georgia’s permission to open it. When the door swung open, she stepped inside, and the sheer size of the space took her breath away. The high ceilings, walls with perfect lighting, and the massive windows overlooking the estate gave her the perfect natural lighting.

“Your studio is 4,000 square feet; it’s a genuine artist’s studio.”

She set the painting she had completed, still wet, on an easel that was center stage when she entered. It was the only thing that felt like hers. She thought about the name she’d given it... “HATE.” The emotion that defined her. The emotion that would define everything moving forward.

Every inch around her is filled with high-end easels, canvases, paintbrushes, and sleek digital workstations. She moved toward the massive shelves lining the walls, filled with perfectly organized supplies.

This was what she’d always wanted, a space free of distractions where she could create.

And yet, there was something unsettling about it. She hated it. She loved it—but she hated it! She stood there, caught between admiration and loathing, a dizzying feeling swelling in her chest.

Georgia’s phone buzzed. She glanced at the screen before addressing Alexia. “The packers will be here in an hour, Miss Marque.”

The movers were professional, but the last part of her old life was slipping away, and there was nothing she could do about it.

She cursed him under her breath. “Damn you, Elliot. I hate you!”

Then came the real surprise: Jonathan, the driver, entered and handed her the keys to a brand-new Mercedes. It was a business perk from Elliot, and it was all in her name—insurance, papers, everything.

Alexia recognized Jonathan’s voice. The note. She understood it all now.

Elliot had been manipulating her since the beginning. The suite, the studio, and now a Mercedes. He had to have planned it for at least three months.

Did he cause her to lose the three art exhibitions over the past three months? Is this just another gilded cage?

She cursed him under her breath. “Damn you, Elliot. I hate you!”

She stared at the keys, anger rising in her chest, and on her way out of the studio, she mentioned she’d be back later.

Outside, there sat the Mercedes. She slid in, pushed the engine start button, and drove down the winding driveway.

“Damn you, Elliot! You are going to regret this! You will pay more than you know! I’m not your prize to cage! Breathe... stop... stop now.”

She exited the estate. I need a drink…

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter