The sun climbed higher, casting harsh light over the grim scene. Martin’s body had been moved to a shaded area beneath the trees, covered with a makeshift shroud of palm leaves. The group stood a short distance away, the weight of the situation hanging over them like a dark cloud.

Edward Carrington, ever the leader, addressed the group. His voice was steady, but the tension in his words was undeniable. “We can’t ignore the reality of what’s happened. One of us… one of us pushed Martin off that cliff. We need to figure out who.”

“Isn’t it a bit too soon to start pointing fingers?” Paul Henderson interjected, his usual jovial tone replaced with unease. “We barely know each other. For all we know, it really could have been an accident.”

“Accident?” James Sterling’s voice was sharp. “Did you see how he fell? That rock didn’t just slip on its own.”

Victoria Gray, standing beside James, nodded in agreement. “James is right. Someone had to have been up there with him. We need to be honest with each other, or none of us are getting off this island alive.”

Nina Wells, who had been silent until now, spoke up, her voice trembling. “But how do we know who to trust? We can’t just start accusing people without proof.”

Lillian Thorne, her expression distant, added, “Trust is a luxury we don’t have anymore. The moment Martin died, everything changed.”

The group fell into a tense silence, each member lost in their thoughts. The sense of camaraderie that had briefly formed after the shipwreck was rapidly disintegrating, replaced by suspicion and fear.

Dr. Alice Monroe, who had been observing the others quietly, finally spoke, her voice calm but firm. “We need to approach this logically. Panic and accusations won’t help us. We need to gather information—figure out who was where, who saw what. It’s the only way we’ll get to the truth.”

Edward nodded in agreement. “Alright, let’s go over everything we know. We’ll each recount our movements from last night and this morning. If there’s a hole in someone’s story, we’ll find it.”

One by one, they recounted their activities. Edward and Paul had been on watch during the second shift, patrolling the perimeter of the camp. Dr. Monroe and Edward had searched the southern beach in the morning. Nina and Paul had searched the eastern forest, while James and Victoria had headed towards the cliffs.

You might be reading a stolen copy. Visit Royal Road for the authentic version.

Each story was consistent, but there was one problem: no one could account for Martin’s movements before he disappeared. He had been restless, irritated, and eager to take action, but beyond that, no one had noticed anything unusual. It was as if he had simply vanished, only to reappear as a lifeless body at the bottom of the cliff.

“Well, that’s helpful,” Paul muttered, frustration seeping into his voice. “We’re no closer to figuring out who did this.”

“There has to be something we’re missing,” Victoria insisted, her mind racing. “People don’t just die like this without reason. Maybe Martin knew something, or maybe he found something on the island. Something that made him a target.”

Lillian, who had been listening intently, looked up suddenly, her eyes narrowing. “What if it wasn’t about Martin at all? What if he was just in the wrong place at the wrong time?”

James frowned, considering her words. “You mean, the killer didn’t intend for it to be him?”

Lillian nodded slowly. “Think about it. We’ve all been thrown into this situation together, but we know nothing about each other’s pasts. We don’t know who might have a reason to kill.”

Dr. Monroe crossed her arms, her expression thoughtful. “That’s true. But it also means that any one of us could be the next target.”

A heavy silence fell over the group. The possibility that Martin’s death was just the beginning—a prelude to more violence—settled over them like a shroud. The island had become a prison, with danger lurking behind every tree, in every shadow.

Edward, sensing the growing unease, spoke up again. “We need to stick together. No one goes anywhere alone. And we need to find a way to signal for help as soon as possible. If we’re going to survive, we can’t afford to turn on each other.”

But his words, though logical, rang hollow. The seeds of distrust had already been planted, and no amount of planning could remove them. The survivors were now bound together by more than just their situation—they were bound by the knowledge that one of them was a murderer.

As the day wore on, the group tried to busy themselves with tasks—collecting food, fortifying the camp, scouting for a place to build a signal fire—but the tension remained, a constant undercurrent. Every glance, every word was weighed with suspicion. Who among them had taken a life? And who would be next?

As the sun began to set, casting long shadows across the island, the group gathered around the fire once more. The atmosphere was heavy, the unspoken accusations thick in the air. They had survived another day, but the question loomed: how many more would they have left?

The island was silent, save for the crackling of the fire and the distant sound of the waves. But in that silence, the survivors knew that the worst was yet to come. The first death had shattered their fragile unity, and the knowledge that a killer walked among them would continue to erode their trust.

As darkness fell, the survivors settled in for another restless night. But sleep did not come easily. Each of them lay awake, their minds racing, haunted by the same question: who among them could they trust?

And as they stared into the darkness, each of them knew that the answer might come too late.