This story is a retrospective from the main character Epimetheus (Theo) Summers. He is a new high school student who has recently moved to the town of Ravencrest New Jersey. Theo has always been interested in horror due to the fact that biologically his unable to feel fear. In his new town he encounters the legend of the Ravencrest Reaper which involves a mythical killer who reappears every few years. After a murder signifies the Reapers resurgence Theo and the Scooby gang he assembles takes it upon themselves to unravel the mystery put in front of them. Things do not end well...