In the early 2000s, Cynthia and James, former college sweethearts, meet at a medieval-themed cafe on a chilly winter day. While James hopes to rekindle their past romance, Cynthia plans to reveal her recent engagement. As they reminisce, James must come to terms with the finality of their relationship, while Cynthia wrestles with nostalgia and a lingering love that has long since faded into bittersweet memories. In the warmth of the cafe, they both realize that though they once meant everything to each other, their lives have moved in different directions.